Connecting Weblogs and KnowledgeBoard

15-Jun-04

I gave a presentation on Weblogs and how Weblogs and KnowledgeBoard can connect to each other at the SIG Editors meeting in Lisbon on June 1st. This article summarises the points I talked about and that were discussed.

Why I came to the meeting
A couple of weeks ago I was asked by a group of KnowledgeBoard members to join their discussion on Weblogs. They had started to meet in chats regularly to talk about how Weblogs and KnowledgeBoard could connect to eachother better. If you search KnowledgeBoard for the word "Weblog" you will see why: There was more and more discussion boiling up around Weblogs and the group felt it was the time to come to concrete insights about what KnowledgeBoard should have to do in its relationship with Weblogs. I helped by contributing my knowledge and experience of Weblogs and we shaped our ideas into a proposal of what KnowledgeBoard could do. The timing was just right for the Lisbon meeting, so I was invited to give my talk here and help facilitate the discussion about connecting Weblogs and KnowledgeBoard. I have a personal interest in this, because I would love to connect to KnowledgeBoard better with my Weblog, but I will talk more about that later.

Blogs and Blogging
Some introductury ideas about Weblogs and Blogging can be found in the Mindmap that is attached to this article.

People use Weblogs for personal journalling. They collect thoughts and links and reflect. They publish to a personal audience and enter in discussions with their readers and other webloggers. Discussion with others works in different ways: Comments (very much like comments on KnowledgeBoard), E-Mail or Posts on other Weblogs.

What is important is to notice that Blogging is Writing and Reading. Bloggers use the "RSS"-Technology to be able to follow many different sources.

RSS
RSS is a machine readable (XML) Format for content of regularly changing websites. It can be used to "subscribe" to "feeds" of new entries from a source. These feeds are published automatically be every weblog. By aggregating different feeds in one interface, you save a lot of time by seeing automatically, what has changed and by being able to skim content very fast. (I gave a demo of this in Lisbon.) Using RSS is the natural way of following content for many people.

Why do people publish on Weblogs rather that posting to KnowledgeBoard?
Important: It's not a question of "either-or". Many bloggers are also active on KnowledgeBoard and many KnowledgeBoard members also blog. They are using different mediums, different channels for different goals.
This is a very complex issue and explaining it in detail would go too far here. If you, dear reader, were not present at the meeting in Lisbon and have some specific questions on this, please do ask questions in the comments.
The important point is: Bloggers have very good reasons for blogging. They are not "not-posting" on KnowledgeBoard because of a lack of features, but have specific, personal goals that they want to accomplish by publishing on a Weblog. The question for KnowledgeBoard should not be "What can we do to get bloggers 'back' to KnowledgeBoard?" but rather "How can KnowledgeBoard benefit from these (very active!) users?"!

So... what can be done? Now we get to the important part.

What SIG Editors could do:

  • Start Reading Weblogs. You can start at the KnowledgeBoard Blogroll - a list of Weblogs of KnowledgeBoard members - to find interesting weblogs. Get yourself an RSS-Aggregator - you can install them on your PC or use a service on the web like bloglines.com. Here is an example of how that looks like:
    http://www.bloglines.com/public/KnowledgeBoard
  • Feature interesting articles on your SIG. This happened with an article that was originally published by Martin Dugage on his Weblog and generated an exteremely valuable discussion.
    http://www.knowledgeboard.com/item/125824
    http://blog.mopsos.com/archives/000080.html
  • Implementations on KnowledgeBoard
    1) Integrate Weblog-URLs into personal profiles of users. At the moment, the KB-Blogroll (the list of all KnowledgeBoard members with a Weblog) is produced manually. It would save a lot of work and improve quality if it was created automatically. This list of Weblogs of KB members would be an interesting starting point for SIG editors and other users who want to broaden their reading.

    2) Implement RSS-Feeds. This connects to an important point Martin Dugage brought up in his talk about Communities of Practice: Many people seldomly surf to the homepage of a community to find out what is happening. Publishing RSS-Feeds would lower the barrier of following new content and discussions on KnowledgeBoard. I shared my own story of how following what is going on on KnowledgeBoard is quite difficult and requires me to "start an extra process". It is not part of my daily information work. If KnowledgeBoard produced RSS, I could more easily follow what is going on and be able to participate more.
    Feeds could be produced for different items: New posts on SIGs and Zones, new comments, new members etc.

    3) Implement TrackBack. Bloggers are already writing about KB-stories on their Weblogs - but KB-members cannot notice! TrackBack is a fairly simple technology that was developed in Weblogs that makes it possible to notify a website that you have written about it. If KnowledgeBoard was "trackback-enabled", it would be possible to see where discussions about KB-items are going on on Weblogs. Every article could have links to the weblog-discussions going on elsewhere, that today are just lost. (Again, I shared a couple of stories of how I blogged about KB-items on my Weblog and how it was a pity that the content of the discussion that ensued on my blog was not fed back to KnowledgeBoard - the two communities were not connecting to eachother.)

    There were many questions and a very long discussion. I hope I was able to answer most questions.

    What was clear is that the issue of connectiong weblogs to KnowledgeBoard is an important one and that it should be emphasized in the future development of the site. Anne Jubert suggested to start a working group that researches concrete ways of connecting Weblogs and KB further and Anne Bennett of Sift said she wanted to join the group. Other people present at the meeting also showed interest in participating and I am sure that there will be more KB-members who participated in discussion about Weblogs in the last months that will want to join.

    It was an honour for me to be invited to this meeting and I would be glad if I could continue to work on this subject as an advisor to the working group.

    Acknowledgement
    I would like to thank the members of H-SIG and the other members of KnowledgeBoard who were involved in the preparations and the work, especially Ton Zijlstra, who wrote the proposal together with me and should be credited just as much as me, Lilia Efimova, who helped me shape the outline of my talk and who's blog-archive was full of great ideas that we built on, Jacques Souillot, who was always there when I needed feedback and Cindy Lemcke-Hoong whose energy kept us all going.

    Technical Notes
    A technical note on the documents attached: The first file contains my presentation slides in PDF format. They do not contain a lot of content by themselves and serve more as an aid to memory for participants. The second file is a mindmap which I used in the first part of the presentation. It is in Freemind-Format. Freemind is a free, java-based mindmapping software which I highly recommend. You can read my review of the software (in German). The third file is an HTML-Export of the mindmap and the fourth a JPG-(image)version of it so you don't have to get the software to look at the map.

Details

Martin Roell

Attachments: 4

Author:
Martin Roell
Publisher:
KnowledgeBoard
Date:
15-Jun-04
Categories:
Communities and Collaboration, CoPs, Human and Social, Human Side of KM 
Sections:
News

This article has been read 13151 times.

Member comments (8)

Share your views with other users: add your own comments to this item.

Mohamed Taher
Mohamed Taher, 23-Jun-06 @ 04:46AM
Blog As A Teaching Tool

Your approach is excellent. Thank you for the detailed analysis.

Was wondering if your post will be updated to reflect the emerging trends in knowledge sharing through blogs, podcasting, etc.? Also, with the advancement in RSS feeds, reading lists from any blog can be easily updated, I understand. I did give a try with Blogbridge. But, yet to see its true colors.

I recently did a presentation on Blog As A Teaching Tool. Have a look at the post, and you will find some KM related citations, included with a purpose of being inclusive.

Will be happy to receive your comments on my blogging research. i am continuously updating the content to stay updated.

Feel free to contact me.
Best, Mohamed Taher
enail: mt2222@yahoo.com

Ed Mitchell
Ed Mitchell, 21-Jun-04 @ 16:21PM
Thanks Martin

I hope I'm up to date on the concepts and tools, I'm reading some more stuff on the train tonight on topic sharing infrastructures (not just agregation) and Anne is going to get to work on the workgroup with you guys very soon. We're sorting the IP issues here too, and very keen to retain the concept of KB as a 'clutter-free' zone amid all the hustle and bustle of the blogsphere... and KB's future architecture and how that relates to the outward content syndication, and how *that* relates to the backend technology being worked on in Sift... :)

Martin Röll
Martin Röll, 21-Jun-04 @ 15:58PM
Some answers

Cindy: Creating a meaningful stream of content from Weblogs by using RSS is not trivial. It is possible to use some automatic filtering but the filters will have to be adjusted by men - or the feed will just be a mess of content of little relevancy. More important that syndicating content from Weblogs onto KB however is that KB produces its own RSS-feeds, so it can be read via newsaggregators.

Aber the copyright issue: The Bloggers own the rights to their content. Syndicating RSS-Feeds is widely accepted, but still it is good practise to ask Bloggers first if you want to republish their feeds.

Ed: Welcome! Let me know if you need advice on RSS or other matters around the connections between KnowledgeBoard and Weblogs.

Ton: You just signed up. :) I suggest we use this comment thread to start off the group. So if you want to join the group, please comment here!

Denham Grey
Denham Grey, 19-Jun-04 @ 15:14PM
Collecting the record

Having a way to connect bloggers to KnowledgeBoard is a very worthwhile goal. I'm sure it will help to increase 'hits' and peripheral participation.

I'm hoping that designers here at KB will seek ways to collect scattered posts and build a record that is persistent and easy to navigate.

One major drawback of blog conversations is their distributed nature. It is no easy feat to follow along and to reconstruct the flows - RSS and blog channels and trackback not withstanding. Blogs disperse thoughts and collecting them in a readable record is not easy. Some suggestions:

* Appoint a cybrarian to track , summarize and gather topic centered key posts.
* Establish a common 'ontology' - classification system or set of categories that KM bloggers can use to index their posts.
* Subscribe to the KM blog channel and encourage folks to ping their posts
* Find an elegant way to incorporate comments on individual blogs into a central record as these often have more value that the original blog posts.

http://topicexchange.com/t/knowledge_management/

Your thoughts?

Ton Zijlstra
Ton Zijlstra, 19-Jun-04 @ 14:23PM
Let's get going!

Hi Martin, all,

Thanks Martin for documenting your impressions here. And a welcome to Ed as our temporary editor at KB!

I look forward to start working together on bringing the points discussed in Lisbon to action. So where do I sign up for the workgroup that was decided?

best,

Ton

Ed Mitchell
Ed Mitchell, 18-Jun-04 @ 10:28AM
Plenty to think about

Hi all,

for those here I haven't met yet, my name is Ed, I am editing KB while Stephanie is away on maternity leave. I read this and thoroughly enjoyed it.

We are approaching this in Sift; Anne Bennett (my boss) is on the recently-formed working group, and I am putting together a request internally to kick the technical investigation/specification/build process off. Martin's comments will be appearing in my report. Thanks :)

There is no doubt that this development will inspire many new issues for the KB community to deal with (the full spectrum of human and technical and knowledge). If we start simply and modestly, we can approach these gently and logically, and get it as right as possible.

My aim is to get some testing up and running as soon as possible from our end, but no doubt, the technical staff will have issues too!

Cindy Lemcke-Hoong
Cindy Lemcke-Hoong, 18-Jun-04 @ 03:49AM
What is next?

Hello Martin,

Thank you for spending the time to give our readers a very complete picture of your presentation at Lisbon.

As a person who does not know much about RSS, I can see we use RSS feed to pipe in 'text' from blogs, but is there some mechanism where we can select what we need? Different catagory of interests. For example.

Would you be discussing how to deal with editorial? Any thoughts on copyrights? Or should we practice copyleft? You mentioned about track-back AND I am already seeing some very interesting situations.

Cindy

Jacques SOUILLOT
Jacques SOUILLOT, 16-Jun-04 @ 16:58PM
Clarity and exhaustivity! Bravo!!!

Such a well documented and transparent report!

Thanks Martin.